PS2 vs HDD Media Player vs DIVX capable DVD Player

Posted: June 6, 2008 in Hardware, Software
Tags: , , , , , ,

I have RM500 (ceiling RM600) to be spend as my home entertainment hub. And it is pretty hard for me to buy one. For months, I can’t actually decide which one should I go ; either Sarotek Media Player (2.5 inch HDD base) or well establish brand DVD player with DIVX/XVID/MP4 capabilities.

A couple of visit to Giant Kelana Jaya, SenHeng, Digital Mall and even Low Yat plaza still can’t help me to decide which one should I go.

Cheap brand like Pensonic got DIVX capable DVD Player but with very limited function. Can’t blame it with sub RM 200 price tags. Some of these cheap DVD player support WMV but not DIVX, some support DIVX but not XVID, some has USB but can’t played divx via USB…only for music ripping…bleh.

Moving to sub RM500 but above RM350 DVD player reveal more option for me. Have better support for DVD+R, DVD-R, RW and even DVD-RAM. Support DIVX, WMV and MP4 mostly. Half of them got not USB extension and how about firmware update. What if new version DIVX and XVID released and people start to encode their movie using latest codec. Will that player still able to play that movie without firmware update. One thing that annoy me with firmware update is : Most of the manufacturer claim that the firmware is upgradeable but heck…nobody could find the latest firmware. Look like, the customer need to buy new player instead. This is my major concern, as codec evolve pretty rapid these days. And I dont want to spend RM 500 to something that will absolute in 1 or 2 years.

Second alternative is HDD base Media Player like Sarotek Media Player. Basically, it is 2.5 inch (notebook) hard disk casing with multimedia function (capable to play divx, xvid, mp3, mp4) and remote control. The case alone will cost me RM450+. Hard Disk not included. Expect to spend another RM150 for the hard disk. This alternative sound pretty good to me. It use less space than dedicated DVD player with mp4 capabilities and has at least 120 GB of storage. Around 171 divx movies. Hmmm…

Suddenly, I found a web page which explain how to make a PlayStation 2 as Home Entertainment Hub with a single boot CD (which is the author is kind enough to pre-made it and host it). According to the author, with this boot CD (which bypass PS2 OS and load up SMS Media Player), PS2 could play DVD Movie, divx, xvid, mp4, mp3 from various type of resource; either DVD-+R, CD-R, USB (External HDD, Pendrive, Memory Card Reader), LAN (Lan storage), even HDD itself). I was about…holy crap..this is excellent. A free home brewed boot disc which able to transform PS2 gaming console into full fledge Home Entertainment HUB.

A quick check at Lowyat.net forum and Sungai Wang Plaza, brand new PS2 will cost you around RM380 to RM599 depending on package. As my previous post I settle with RM550.00 package which give me a new version of PS2 console (90006 slim) + 1 original controller + 1 look like original but not so controller + 1 8 MB original memory card + 1 PS2 travel case + AV cable.

So, why did I choose PS2 instead of Sarotek HDD Media Player? Sarotek HDD Media Player, albeit it will cost me another RM50 compare to PS2, I got 120 GB of storage space. A dedicated storage space for my movie alone. But, some issue with HDD base media player. One is the firmware. What if the manufacturer stop or actually never release new firmware? What if the remote control lost or damage (most hdd base media player 80% depend on remote control for its operation). When HDD is one of the component in the system, durability and reliability become a major concern.

And the ultimate reason is : I spend RM 600 for a multimedia player only BUT for RM 550 (PS2), I got multimedia player and 1001 PS2 games (which cost me RM3 to RM 5 each) console. Game console alone worth the RM500 (which I could spend countless of quality hour with my wife watching our divx movie collection and play our favorite games together), let alone it limitless capability on playing what ever format / codec. As long as PS2 community still exist, there will be nonstop of supply home brewed applications from them.

Next : How to make your PS2 –> Multimedia and Multiformat Media Player (Pre-Made installer/image and step by step Guide). Read Here

Comments
  1. Guess who will this be.
    The hint is, I do not normally type like this.
    I am only one of the fans of the rose you are running, and I still play on it. I played the previous solarose before it its sudden death.

    Your post reminded me about the story of fast food stores drive thou ordering. It is always natural to assume the person speaking to you when you order to be the person serving you the mean. This is not true however. They have a different person talking to you. Perhaps, somewhere far enough for a need to go to the airport. The shop then recieves order from their internet system and they prepare the food just as you drive to the counter to collect the food you ordered.

    The growing reliance of internet and communication is surprising large. When I was away for my holiday ages ago, we had a very terrible incident that rendered the internet useless because of a breakage of some underwater connection line. If this happens in a few years time later, I cannot imagine the impact of this.

  2. Alberto says:

    Well, frankly the PS2 its not too good to play divx/xvid, i used a pendrive to load movies, played 8 1/2 with divx encoding, and all was ok, i noticed that the video bitrate was a bit lower, i left the movie about 50 minutes, then load the movie on my pc, great improvement (mostly on the video fluidness) the color was the same, also the audio, but video on the ps2 its some sloppy, thats my experience, also you will need a modchip, swap magic, action replay, gameshark, or a memory card trick with a friends ps2 to put in the “exploit” (i remember browsing on ebay and watched preloaded ps2 memory cards) and then load ps2 applications.

  3. expertester says:

    Alberto….

    Well Alberto, I believe poor playback (divx movie) in your case is not caused by PS2 but your Media Player itself. I use the above media player, I don’t see any choppiness or slow framerate. In fact, the color saturation and warmness look better at my tv instead of my Samsung LCD monitor.

    Since my PS2 already modded, what I need is that software which I post above. Burn in into a CDR and boot PS2 with that disc..bingo.

  4. Albert says:

    If I may make a suggestion. I have a Philips DVP5990 DVD player and I have a Western Digital “My Book” 500GB drive that I have hooked up to it and I am able to play Divx/Xvid/WMV through the USB port without a problem. I did not have to make any modifications to anything. Don’t know if you found what you wanted but I hope that this helps. Too much info on the drive does make it skip I am still working to see how much I can fit without the problem. Right now I use about half of the drive wit no problem.

  5. kar0 says:

    i bought a ps2 last week at sungei wang cost me RM500
    console(premodded),1 ori controller(RM60 each), 1 fake controller(RM20 each) and 1 memory card
    then i ask to change fake controller to ori wan and ask 4 1 vertical stand.
    It cost me RM555 for console, 2 ori controller, 1 memory and 1 vertical stand(which he say is made from sony) and he say it is CNY special. BTW the games there is RM10 each so i didnt buy there.🙂

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s